'I do not preach what I do not practice': White's steakhouse
White called preaching one thing and not practicing another 'dissimulation, a kind of hypocrisy' — and assured that she never made an exception in her own case.
By Rodrigo Custódio ·
It was one of the most requested videos on the channel: did Ellen White eat meat after receiving the health message? Was she, in the words of her own writings, a hypocrite? Rodrigo promises a quick video, with the texts directly on screen — first the standard she set for everyone, then what the records show about her own table. The date that organizes everything is June 6, 1863, when she received the health reform vision.
The standard she herself established
The first texts are about others. Can we have confidence in ministers who, at the table where meat is served, join others in eating it? Ministers who disregard the light on health reform have their piety weakened — and, White writes, "no man should be set apart as a teacher of the people while his own teaching or example contradicts the testimony God has given to His servants with regard to diet"; whoever despises health reform "is disqualified to stand as a messenger of the Lord." Defending on paper what one does not practice at one's own table has a name, in her pen: "This is dissimulation — a kind of hypocrisy."
And about herself, she was equally explicit. In 1869, she recorded: "I have not changed my course a particle since I adopted the health reform. I have not taken one step backward since the light of heaven shone upon this subject in my path. I broke with everything at once: with meat, with butter, and with three meals. I took my position on health reform on principle." In 1886, she reaffirmed the same line — the sentence that the video places side by side with the records of the previous years:
"I do not preach one thing and practice another. I do not present to my hearers rules of life for them to follow while I make an exception in my own case."
The table the records document: roast meat and chicken by candlelight — years after the 1863 message.
1873–1878: venison, beef broth and the Christmas roast
Ten years after the 1863 vision, a young hunter from Nova Scotia returned from a 32-kilometer trip with a quarter of venison on his back, saw six moose along the way and gave the White family a piece of the meat — which, the text records, "we made into broth." On a boat trip, seasick to the point of not getting up from Monday to Thursday, she took, during that period, a broth — beef, the video emphasizes, not tomato — with biscuit. And on Christmas morning of 1878, with the house full — James, the children, visitors and the cook — the table had a quarter of an animal cooked and stuffed, "as tender as chicken," which, in the words of the record, everyone enjoyed very much. Venison, the narration observes, seems to have been one of her favorites.
1880–1884: pressed chicken, oysters and more chicken
In 1880, seventeen years after the message, breakfast was a portion of pressed chicken, provided by the matron of the sanitarium, placed in a two-liter bucket on the stove — "and so we had a good hot chicken broth." In a letter to Mary, she asks: "If you can get me a good box of fresh herring, please do so. The last ones Willy bought are bitter and old" — and adds the request for cans of tomato and "a few cans of good oysters." In 1884, twenty-one years after the vision, the record of a home where she was staying notes the "good food and in abundance": the hostess scalded the chicken, and the meat would be scalded the next morning.
The question that remains
The video closes by returning the standard to its owner. If defending a position without putting it to the test at one's own table is dissimulation; if a minister who eats meat is disqualified as a messenger; if she assured, in 1869 and again in 1886, that she made no exception in her own case — how is one to describe the venison of 1873, the roast of Christmas 1878, the chicken of 1880, the oysters of 1882 and the scalded chicken of 1884? The narration does not ask the viewer to accept a ready-made conclusion: the texts are on screen, with the dates, to be paused and read. And it leaves the final invitation to also check out the video about the supernatural manifestations in White's services — the other half of the portrait that, according to the channel, the denomination never presented to its members.
Read also
Read also: They took his notebook in colporteur work: Ed Gonçalves →
Read also: 'She never said it is a sin': White against meat →
Read also: Ellen White confesses: I ate a little meat →
Watch the full video
Ellen White's texts and the records of her meals, year by year, are in the video below: