The Censored Vision: Abraham Was Already in Heaven, She Said
The video compares 'A Word to the Little Flock' (1847) and 'Early Writings' side by side: in Ellen White's first vision there was a passage — the patriarchs, martyrs and…
By Rodrigo Custódio ·
The video opens with an unlikely comparison: McDonald's. The chain sells consistency — the same product, with the same quality, anywhere in the world. Adventism, the presenter argues, fails in exactly that regard when it comes to Ellen White: the story changes depending on the edition. And no example shows this better than her first vision, published in 1847 — and republished later with one passage missing.
The standard she herself set
Before opening the books, the video establishes Ellen White's own criterion, repeated by an authority from the White Estate in a clip shown at the beginning:
"The testimonies are of the Spirit of God or of the devil. There is no middle ground in this matter."
If everything she wrote came 100% from God — as the organization affirms when it calls her an authority and the "spirit of prophecy" — then the question that structures the entire video arises: do you believe God would send Ellen White a lying vision? If the answer is no, the rest must be faced head-on.
Two books, one vision — and one passage missing
On the table, two books. The first is "A Word to the Little Flock" (1847), where the first vision was originally published. The second is "Early Writings," the 1851/1858 compilation through which Adventists know the vision to this day. Placing the two editions side by side, the video highlights in yellow the portion of the text that exists in 1847 and simply is not in the later edition. The sentences immediately before and after the passage fit perfectly into the new version — they arrived there and were erased.

The comparison is physical: the 1847 vision, in 'A Word to the Little Flock,' beside the same vision in 'Early Writings' — with one passage missing.
The preface that swears nothing changed
Most serious of all, for the presenter, is the preface to "Early Writings." In it, the editors assure the reader that no part of the original work was omitted, that no idea or sentiment was altered, that there were only occasional verbal adjustments — and that all changes were made under the author's own supervision, with her full approval. Whoever reads the preface believes they are holding the complete text. They are not.
What the passage said: the patriarchs already in heaven
And why did this passage, specifically, have to disappear? In the censored portion of the vision, Ellen is taken to a most holy place where the ark of the covenant, Aaron's rod, the pot of manna and clusters of grapes are — and where Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Noah, Daniel and Moses already dwell. The vision also places in heaven martyrs and children who died. The problem is doctrinal and obvious: if the patriarchs were already in heaven when she had the vision, then those who die do not "sleep" unconsciously until the resurrection. The passage directly contradicts the doctrine of the sleep of the soul — one of the pillars of Adventism.
Her defense — and the hole in it
Years later, in Selected Messages (p. 65), Ellen herself admitted the suppression — "I felt it necessary to suppress that passage" — and built her defense on four points: she had accepted the doctrine of the sleep of the soul as early as 1844; she never defended any other belief about the dead; and, in the visions, she was transported to the future, to the time when the resurrected saints will be gathered in the kingdom.
The video responds with the text of the vision itself. In it, Ellen says she tried to bring back "grapes from the heavenly Canaan" as a report of what she saw, and she relates that Jesus prevented her from eating the fruit of the tree of life with a revealing argument: whoever ate the fruit of that land would never return to Earth again. If all of that was merely a future scene that does not yet exist, how could she be held there? A place that does not exist holds no one. And if the vision came from God, God does not lie — those who edited God's vision were men, to protect a doctrine.
The video ends with the question returned to pastors and members who have already preached this vision with the book open in the pulpit: did you know you were reading an incomplete message — censored precisely at the point where it said the opposite of what the church teaches?
Read also
5 marks of a cult: check whether your church has them →
Ellen White and the dead in the first vision →
Conditional immortality and the sleep of the soul →