History of Millerism

They Wept Until Dawn: The Day After October 22

Episode 2 of the series: what happened to the Millerites after Jesus did not return.

By Rodrigo Custódio ·

They Wept Until Dawn: The Day After October 22

Jesus did not return on October 22, 1844. And on the 23rd? Episode 2 of the series "The Truth About Adventism," from the Para Que Possamos channel, sets aside William Miller's calculations and looks at the people: what happened to the hundreds of thousands of believers who sold everything, put on white robes and waited for the sky to open? The answer, according to the video, divides into four destinies — and into the seeds of six new religious movements.

The Early Hours of October 23

The days following the Great Disappointment are difficult to describe even today, says the episode. Thousands wept until they had no strength left; hundreds, ashamed of the jokes and mockery, fled and hid in forests and other cities for weeks and months. The best-known account is that of Hiram Edson, one of the most faithful followers of Millerism, who described the following 24 hours: the day passed, nothing happened, and disappointment turned to certainty. "Our fondest hopes and expectations were blasted," the video records from Edson's testimony, as he questioned whether, that hope having failed, the Bible itself and faith might not also be a failure:

"We wept and wept until the dawn."

The host is careful to note: today it may seem easy to ridicule these believers, but anyone who looks closely at the devastating effects of the disappointment realizes the damage that a faith placed without examination in men and interpretations can cause in a person's life.

Group 1: Those Who Stayed — and Reset the Date

The first group gathered the Millerites who remained faithful to the movement. They continued meeting in the Millerite tabernacle, with daily services and vigils — but believers of different opinions and interpretations shared the same space, which generated serious conflicts between scholars and fanatics. It was from this core, according to the episode, that new dates for Christ's return and new biblical theories publicly presented were born: instead of revisiting the premise, part of the group preferred to recalculate the conclusion.

Tecidos brancos pendurados sobre cerca de madeira rústica ao lado de estrada de terra em colina enevoada ao amanhecer

The ascension robes were left behind: for the Millerites, October 23, 1844 was the first day of the rest of their lives.

Groups 2 and 3: Those Who Returned — and Those Who Fled

The second group took the path of self-criticism: they admitted they had believed a fable, endured the humiliation and returned to the churches they had left — Baptist, Methodist, Presbyterian and others — resuming the religious life they had before Miller. The third group could not bear the shame of staying: they fled to states and cities where no one knew them and started over without presenting themselves as Millerites. Many, the video states, never recovered from the trauma: there are records of people committed to asylums in the region, and family members reported that, years later, some still held to the hope that the promise would be fulfilled.

Group 4: Those Who Lost Everything

The fourth group is the grimmest. It includes, on one hand, those who took their own lives, preferring not to live with the pain and trauma of the disappointment; on the other, those who had sold all their possessions — houses, clothes, animals, machinery — or abandoned their jobs and awoke in complete destitution. The damage was not only religious but social: city governments and local leaders had to organize, and there are records in Boston and New York of government programs created to shelter and feed those who had lost everything. According to the episode, these were lost lives, broken minds and families fleeing their own reality — the damage caused by Miller's calculation was only beginning.

Miller's Silence and the Letter of November 10

While the followers divided, the leader remained silent — not for a day or two, but for weeks, which left many people worried about the movement's future. The first attempt to regroup came from Joshua Himes, who on October 31, 1844 published in the newspaper Midnight Cry an appeal for the Millerites to help those who had hastily left their jobs and sold their possessions. Only on November 10 did Miller speak in writing: he said that, although disappointed twice, he was neither cast down nor discouraged; that his hope in Christ was stronger than ever; and that the duty of believers was to comfort one another and live by faith. For the host, however, it was too late: when Miller finally spoke, Millerism was already dead — and the absence of leadership at the decisive moment opened the space for others to fill the void.

From the Vacuum, Six Movements

Followers began to question Miller's leadership and teachings, and internal groups formed movements of their own, which would transform the religious landscape of the United States: the First-Day Adventists, of Jonathan Cummings; the Advent Christians, linked to Joshua Himes; the Life and Advent Union, of John Walsh and George Storrs; the Future Age Adventists; the spiritualizers, of Turner and Apollos Hale; and the Sabbath-keeping Adventists, led by names that would become central in the next episode — Ellen White, James White, Joseph Bates and Hiram Edson himself. The video's conclusion is an invitation to continue the timeline: all the churches that were born from Millerism carry, in doctrine, culture and behavior, remnants of that October night.

Read Also

Watch the Full Episode

Watch Episode 2 of the series, with the four groups and the movements that were born from the disappointment:

Watch on YouTube: The Day After the Great Disappointment of 1844 - What Happened Next? Adventist Church - Episode 2 →