Adventism

The pastor must choose: Christ or the organization

In the 2024 Easter Eve question-and-answer live stream, Rodrigo launched the official Para Que Possamos website and answered live: why Adventist theologians don't speak the…

By Rodrigo Custódio ·

The pastor must choose: Christ or the organization

On the eve of Easter 2024, Rodrigo opened a live stream without a new documentary — just audience questions and three announcements: the launch of the official Para Que Possamos website, the third season set for April 12, and the relaunch of his friend Wagner Olmos's channel, removed by YouTube and rebuilt from scratch as Remanescente Oficial. Between one answer and another, the live stream became an X-ray of Adventism from the inside: why pastors who have already noticed the problem keep preaching, where the local church's money goes, and what "church" really is.

A website to answer any question in three clicks

The first announcement was the website paraquepossamos.com.br, presented on screen as a study hub: folders by topic (the Ellen White one alone already gathered 19 articles), keyword search, and long articles with bibliographic references. The highlight was the Sabbath School lesson for the quarter on The Great Controversy, commented on and refuted day by day — with a section of "important corrections" that even uses Adventist historians, such as George Knight, to show that Christ's two-phase ministry in the heavenly sanctuary was an exclusively Adventist invention. The site also offers a model letter of resignation from the church, an emotional support group, and a form to submit your own testimony, with an option for anonymity. All free, including to print and distribute.

Why don't theologians speak the truth?

The first Instagram question was the sharpest of the afternoon: why don't Seventh-day Adventist theologians speak the truth about the beliefs they defend? Rodrigo's answer described a funnel. The Adventist pastor, he said, works at a personal crossroads: defend Christ or defend the organization — whoever tries to stay in the middle suffers within the structure itself. Many have already realized that doctrines such as the investigative judgment, the Sabbath as the seal of God, and the Sunday decree do not hold up in the Bible, but they run into two walls. The first is the agenda: elders and directors demand the week of prayer of Revelation, prophetic preaching, the quoting of Ellen White. The second is survival: an Adventist pastor's training is only useful within Adventism; leaving means starting from scratch, seminary included. That is why so many of those who have awakened remain where they are — some preaching Christ "from within" and downplaying official theology, others merely administering the system.

"Either he will defend Christ, or he will defend the organization."

Bíblia aberta sobre uma mesa de estudos, com marcadores coloridos nas páginas, óculos de leitura e um celular em tripé

Instagram and chat questions answered live — and almost all of them, as this live stream shows, already have a full article on the project's website.

Church is people, not a corporate registration number

Asked whether every religious system is corrupted and whether any pure church exists, Rodrigo dismantled the premise: church is not a building, a sign, or a corporate registration number — church is people, and people are imperfect. Any group that grows creates structure: five people studying in a house already need a schedule, a topic, and a destination for the offerings; with three hundred, the "system" is inevitable. The problem, then, is not that a system exists, but whom it serves. As an example of the opposite extreme, he cited the statement attributed to Ellen White that the General Conference would be "the most important and solemn gathering of the universe." The practical guidance came from a phrase by Pr. Tharles Elias that he always repeats: seek the church closest to your Bible. And before committing to a community, do your due diligence: research what the church believes, who the pastor is, and whether there are financial or moral scandals — today you can watch dozens of services online before walking through the door.

The "Adventist Car Wash" is coming

Responding about ARM (Adventist Risk Management), the denomination's risk and insurance manager, Rodrigo gave a name to what he is investigating: a fraud broke out in the South American Division between February and March, and he called it, bluntly, "the Adventist Car Wash." According to him, more than twenty documents and audio recordings have already been collected, and the topic should yield a documentary — probably in the fourth season. The original question embedded another: why do Adventists seem so oblivious to all this? Because, he answered, the ordinary member has no idea how the organization works: they leave home, deposit the 10% at the church, grab their Bible, and go back — and if they hear about fraud, they answer that "God will judge the church," while continuing to fund the structure.

Sabbath: each group created its own kit

On the Sabbath, the answer had two layers. The first is about authority: those who truly keep the Sabbath — by the Torah, by Jewish laws, by tradition — are the Jews; placed side by side with a Jew on a filmed Sabbath, no Adventist would sustain the title of "keeper of the commandments." The second is that each Sabbatarian group assembled its own package: Seventh-day Adventists, Adventists of the Promise, Seventh Day Baptists, and Jews keep different days from one another — and all claim Revelation. In Adventist practice, he summed up, "keeping the Sabbath" has been reduced to not working, plus one or another custom (not lighting the stove, walking to church). And he pointed out where the subject is treated at length: Isaiah 56–58, addressed to the people of Israel, has its own article on the website, in the section on the Sabbath.

Tithe doesn't buy heaven — and a fight over five chairs

Tithing produced the harshest words of the live stream: it is not law, it is not mandatory, and it does not serve for salvation — giving is according to the heart and one's possessions, he taught. Rodrigo criticized Pr. Arilton Oliveira by name for preaching that whoever does not tithe will not go to heaven, and lamented that no conference, union, or division president publicly rebukes him for it. At the end, a story illustrated why he insists that his problem was never with people: in a large church in São Paulo where he served in leadership, the decision to modernize the platform and remove the five chairs from the pulpit ended in a physical fight in the side room, ten minutes before the service, because the elder of the month and his guest demanded the chairs back. "People place value on things that have no value," he concluded — noting that he never had a disappointment with the organization significant enough to motivate the channel: it exists, simply, to encourage Adventists to research the other side. By the way, he declared the matter closed for himself: he no longer keeps the Sabbath — he worships Christ on Sundays.

Read also

Read also: Pr. Mário Baio: 'the church grows, but does not convert' →

Read also: Arilton Oliveira demands the tithe that Malachi never commanded →

Read also: The Sabbath as proof of loyalty is salvation by calendar →

Watch the full live stream

Questions and answers, the website launch, and the behind-the-scenes of the channel — watch the full chat:

Watch on YouTube: Bate-Papo Perguntas e Respostas e Etc →