"Hidden book": the apocrypha that White defended in vision
Rodrigo Silva laughs at the apocryphal gospels in public — but a first-person dramatization has 'Ellen White' respond: she called the apocrypha the 'hidden book'…
By Rodrigo Custódio ·
The video opens with the archaeologist and Adventist apologist Rodrigo Silva laughing at the apocryphal gospels on a program: children turned into pigs, parents killed by a word from the boy Jesus, Gnostic "secrets" told to Mary Magdalene and to Judas. Then the channel turns the microphone around and dramatizes the response of the one the apologist defends: in a first-person dramatization, "Ellen White" confronts Rodrigo Silva by reminding him of what she herself wrote about the apocrypha — and what she herself added to the Bible. The video closes with a song of praise.
The mockery that opens the video
In Silva's account, the apocrypha were written to "fill in what is missing from the gospel" and to "customize" the faith: since the canonical gospels say almost nothing about Jesus' childhood, the apocryphal texts focus on it, with extraordinary wonders — the boy Jesus who turns children into pigs because they wanted to hit him and who strikes down the parents who came to complain. The other half of the ridiculed material is Gnostic: gospels attributed to Mary Magdalene, to Judas and to James, built on a secret knowledge reserved for initiates. It is against this backdrop that the dramatization poses its question.
"I am, for you, an apocryphon to the Bible"
White's dramatized voice starts from the denomination's own fundamental belief no. 18, according to which her writings "speak with prophetic authority" and provide guidance, instruction and correction for the church. If the pioneers recognized her as a bearer of the gift of prophecy, the character argues, then the church already accepts, in practice, an authoritative voice beyond the canon: her writings are not part of Scripture, but function as an additional revelation that "illuminates" the Word. The question put to the apologist is direct: if he rejects all revelation outside the canon, why does he accept hers?
In nineteenth-century family Bibles, the apocrypha were bound between the two Testaments — and the Adventist pioneers distributed them at camp meetings, with study notes.
What she wrote about the "hidden book"
The dramatization then cites the historical record that the Adventist tradition itself preserves. In September 1849, according to the account presented, White took in her hands, in vision, a Bible that contained the apocrypha and declared: "Pure and unadulterated" — calling them the word of God and warning that whoever treats them with contempt, thinking he serves God, would be taken captive by Satan. In January 1850, she recorded the sentence that sums up the video:
I saw that the apocrypha were the hidden book, and that the wise of these last days should understand it.
The video also recalls that James White announced in 1869 an official edition of the apocrypha for Adventist families and that Bibles containing the apocrypha circulated at the movement's camp meetings, with study notes prepared by W. C. White, the prophetess's son. In other words: the founders neither burned nor ridiculed the "hidden book" — they published it.
Six additions that the canon does not contain
The second half of the dramatized speech changes target: if the problem with the apocrypha is adding details that the Scriptures do not contain, what about White's visions? The character lists six examples of content that she presented as revelation and that the Bible does not record: Lucifer as the choir director of the heavenly choir before the fall; worlds inhabited by beings who never sinned and who observe the Earth with interest; an interview in which Satan, cast out of heaven, would have asked to go back on his rebellion; the beginning of the investigative judgment on October 22, 1844, with Christ's entry into the Most Holy Place; Enoch residing on a planet with seven moons; and rules such as the prohibition of tea, coffee and pork, besides the Sabbath as God's seal, without which no one would be saved.
The question that remains
The video does not ask anyone to start believing in the apocrypha; it asks for consistency. If the criterion for rejecting a text is that it goes beyond the canon, the same criterion would reach the writings that belief 18 places alongside the Bible — thousands of scenes of heaven, of other worlds and of encounters between Christ and Satan that the biblical text does not describe. And if the criterion does not apply to White, asks the dramatization, why would it apply to the books she called the "hidden book" and that the pioneers printed? Before laughing at the apocrypha in public, the character concludes, the apologist should look at his own tradition — and at the prophetess that it obliges him to accept.
Read also
- 'Tested and approved'? Wellcome saw the trances of 1842 →
- The defense of Ellen White that Rodrigo Silva does not sustain →
- The sources that Rodrigo Silva does not cite →
Watch
Watch the full video on the channel Para Que Possamos:
Watch on YouTube: Ellen White Refuting Rodrigo Silva - The Apocrypha