Ellen White

Was Adam tempted? What Ellen said vs. what the Bible says

Episode 003 of the series Ellen White and the Bible, from the Para Que Possamos channel: in one minute, Ellen White's expanded narrative of the fall is placed side by side with the account of the…

By Rodrigo Custódio ·

Was Adam tempted? What Ellen said vs. what the Bible says

One minute, one question: what did Ellen White say — and what does the Bible say? This is episode 003 of the series "Ellen White and the Bible," from the Para Que Possamos channel, which places the claims of the founder of Adventism side by side with the biblical text, theme by theme. This time the theme is on the first page of the Bible: was Adam tempted?

The question of the episode

The format of the series is deliberately simple: on one side, the words of Ellen White; on the other, the words of the Bible. In the biblical account of the fall, the one who converses with the serpent is Eve — and the New Testament is explicit: "Adam was not deceived" (1 Tim 2:14); he ate knowing what he was doing. In Ellen White's expanded narrative of Eden, however, the scene gains dialogues, motivations and stages that Genesis does not record, and the temptation comes to reach Adam in a way the biblical text does not describe. The episode places the two versions side by side, without lengthy commentary: the viewer compares and draws their own conclusions.

Jardim verdejante ao amanhecer, com uma árvore carregada de frutos e uma serpente enrolada num galho baixo.

In the biblical account, the one who dialogues with the serpent is Eve — the episode asks where Ellen White's version found Adam's temptation.

Why this theme matters

It may seem like a mere scenic detail, but this is exactly how a "messenger" places herself above the text: first she adds a dialogue here, a motivation there, an entire scene elsewhere — and, before the reader realizes it, the final authority is no longer Genesis but her expanded version. The fall of Adam and Eve is the foundation of the entire doctrine of sin; tampering with it is tampering with the base. If not even the third page of the Bible escaped her additions, the episode suggests the obvious question: what remains of the rest?

Read also

Watch the full video

Watch episode 003 of the series, on the temptation of Adam:

Watch on YouTube: Ellen White and the Bible - 003 - Was Adam tempted →