Pastor Tarles Elias dismantles the 3 Adventist taboos
Pastor Tarles Elias (Teologar channel) responds to the three Adventist taboos: where the new covenant begins, whether evangelicals "keep" Sunday, and what the church of Christ is — and…
By Rodrigo Custódio ·
There is a detail that makes this interview special for the channel: Pastor Tarles Elias, of the Teologar channel, was literally the first person to receive the link to the first video of Para Que Possamos — and he replied with a long email of encouragement. Years later, he sat down for the conversation this article summarizes: the three Adventist taboos in the twenty-first century. Tarles pastored a neo-Pentecostal church for about ten years, left it, wrote a book about the heresies he himself had preached, and today leads the Comunidade Apostólica Livre, in Praia Grande (SP). The three taboos are the three questions anyone leaving Adventism must answer: what changes from one covenant to another? Do evangelicals "keep" Sunday? And what, after all, is the church of Christ?
Taboo 1: where does the New Testament begin?
The first taboo is the boundary between the covenants. For Tarles, the New Testament does not begin theologically at Jesus's birth, but at his death: a testament only takes effect after the death of the testator (Hebrews 9:16). Jesus lived under the old covenant — and that is why so much of what he did and taught belongs to the regime of the law. In the passage from one covenant to another, he proposes three principles: continuity, completeness, and rupture. Circumcision is the precedent for rupture: it predates the law, as does the Sabbath, and yet it was not carried over into the new covenant. With the change of priesthood to the order of Melchizedek, says Hebrews 7:11-12, there is necessarily a change of law. And the new commandment does not lower the requirement — it raises it: to love as Christ loved. James 2:10, in this reading, is not a proof text for the Sabbath: it is the acknowledgment of human inability before the 613 ordinances. The sentence that summarizes the section: we do not keep the commandments in order to be saved, but because we are saved — and whoever is born again does not lose the moral compass.
Taboo 2: do evangelicals "keep" Sunday?
The second taboo dismantles a straw man. No evangelical church "keeps" Sunday from sunset to sunset, as Jews and Adventists keep the Sabbath: Sunday is a day of worship and celebration of the resurrection, not a transferred Sabbath. Romans 14:5-6 treats days and foods in the same chapter and with the same freedom; Colossians 2:16-17 calls the Sabbath a shadow, with Christ being the reality — "I will be your rest," Tarles summarizes. The practical contrast is cutting: the Adventist who misses a Sabbath faces the group's social rebuke; the evangelical who misses a Sunday is simply welcomed back with joy. The problem, therefore, is not the day itself — it is tying the Sabbath to salvation and to the mark of the beast.
It was in a conversation like this one — microphone open and Bible on the table — that Tarles Elias addressed the three subjects Adventism avoids discussing.
Taboo 3: what the church of Christ is
The third taboo is the biggest: the church of Christ is made up of all the saved of all ages, peoples, and tongues — an invisible church, far larger than any denomination or "remnant." This is where Tarles retrieves a phrase from the apologist Natanael Rinaldi: certain sects "speak out of both sides of their mouth." Is Ellen White inspired to the same degree as the Scriptures? Yes. Then is she equal to the Bible? No. Is, is not, is, is not — a loop with no way out. If she has the same degree of inspiration, she has the same weight; if she does not have the same weight, she does not have the same degree. The image of the "lesser light" that illuminates the "greater light" receives the same treatment: it is like pointing a flashlight at the noonday sun hoping to make it brighter. And the argument that "she does not contradict the Bible" does not prove inspiration either: if Tarles wrote that in Eden the tomcats were blue and the she-cats hot pink, none of that would contradict the Bible — it simply would not be in it. Absence of contradiction is not presence of revelation.
And after leaving? The detox
The second half of the conversation is pastoral. Tarles describes the exit as a process of detoxing from a theology of fear — he knows the feeling from the inside: "it feels like a piano is going to fall on my head." His book "Escravos das Heresias" refutes the heresies he himself preached for ten years, and it was from the pulpit that he made the way back, telling the congregation, one by one, the things he had preached wrongly. Why can so many people not leave? He lists them: those who never had access to the truth outside the bubble; the innocent, guided by others' erudition; those who depend financially on the structure; those who seek position; and those who dug too deep — preached, debated, recorded videos — and now need the hardest dose, the humility to say "I was wrong." Quantity is not truth: at Carmel, one prophet faced 850. Success is not truth, erudition is not truth — the path is that of the Bereans, checking everything in the Scriptures. Against the Noah's ark argument ("inside here it stinks, but outside is the flood"), he responds with his parable of the frog that was born in a well and discovered the world: "we have pasture, not a fence" — and he recalls that seven thousand knees did not bow to Baal: there are healthy churches, and each family in transition needs case-by-case accompaniment, not a ready-made package.
Teologar today
The conversation ends with the current work: the Instituto Teologar brings together nearly 5,000 students, with an apologetics course on Adventism of more than 150 lessons and a theology course of more than 300; the channel has passed 200,000 subscribers; and the Comunidade Apostólica Livre already holds three services on Sunday because the space cannot hold everyone at once. The tone of the closing is that of the entire conversation, and Rodrigo records it clearly: nothing against Adventists — beloved relatives included — but against the doctrine that holds them captive. "God opened the Red Sea, raised Lazarus: what is impossible for God?"
Read also
- Even the testimony was copied: the final part of the plagiarisms →
- Sunday is not a papal invention nor the final test →
- The new covenant conditioned on obedience →
Watch the full interview
Watch on YouTube: Interview - Pr. Tarles Elias - Teologar - The 3 Taboos of #Adventists in the 21st Century