Adventism

3 ex-Adventists Respond to Rodrigo Silva Point by Point

Rodrigo Custódio, Gleyson Persio and Wagner Olmos — three ex-Adventists — analyze for more than three hours the video in which Rodrigo Silva defended the Adventist Church against the accusation of…

By Rodrigo Custódio ·

3 ex-Adventists Respond to Rodrigo Silva Point by Point

When Pastor André Valadão replied, in an Instagram question box, that the Seventh-day Adventist Church is a sect, pastor and archaeologist Rodrigo Silva published a video in defense that spread through the country's evangelical churches. The longest response came from those who had once been on the other side: Rodrigo Custódio welcomed Gleyson Persio — author of the series Descortinando o Adventismo — and Wagner Olmos for an analysis of more than three hours, point by point, with Ellen White's books open on the screen. All three are former Adventists, and the invitation they extend right at the opening is that of the Bereans: believe no one — not them, not Silva —; weigh everything on the scales of the Word of God.

Gleyson opens with a historical parallel that, in his view, explains the present moment. In the 1950s, apologist Walter Martin was preparing his book on sects and interviewed Adventists to decide whether to include the denomination. He heard the milder version of the Adventist faith, received the book Questions on Doctrine — full of concessions that did not reflect the church's practice — and classified Adventism gently. According to the account Gleyson brings, from one of Martin's personal assistants, the apologist later concluded, after further study, that he had been deceived. The trio's thesis is that Rodrigo Silva's video plays the same role today: presenting to the outside public a church that, on the inside, operates differently.

Two Discourses: One for the Outside, One for the Inside

The first test proposed is a practical one. In his video, Silva says that he makes appeals in Baptist and Assembly of God churches — "do you accept Jesus as your personal Savior?" — and that people are baptized in those churches as a result of his sermon. Wagner responds with the mirror question: try doing the same inside an Adventist church. No one is baptized in the SDA Church merely by accepting Jesus; and anyone who arrives already baptized from another denomination is informed that the previous baptism did not count and must be redone. On the inside, the three say, the understanding is different: the neighboring church is Babylon, and White wrote that the confessions, prayers and exhortations of the other churches are an abomination in God's eyes. Wagner also reads the comment of a sincere Adventist, which he prefers to the diplomatic version: "I don't mind if they say the Adventist Church is a sect; what matters is that it is the one and only true Christian church that contains the true gospel of Christ."

Sola Scriptura? Practice Belies the Slogan

Silva argued that sola Scriptura denominations reach different conclusions without anyone calling one another a sect — two weights and two measures, in his assessment. The trio's response is that the criterion is not disagreement but the source: in the Adventist church, Ellen White's books are treated on equal footing with the Bible. A service without a reading from her is rare; her interpretations of prophecy were endorsed by her — to question them is to end the discussion with "Sister White saw that it was so"; the health reform, which is not in the Bible, is imposed as a condition even for baptism. Gleyson recalls church committees in which, faced with an impasse — such as the use of drums in the service — the pastor does not open the Bible: he opens the Spirit of Prophecy and decides by it. Wagner recounts that, when he asked to study the book of Hebrews with the church, he was forbidden to open the Bible in the sanctuary, because the text collapses the sanctuary doctrine. And baptism, they recall, requires accepting the gift of prophecy according to fundamental belief 18: White's writings as a "continuing and authoritative source of truth."

"It Is Finished" — But Is the Atonement Still Ongoing Today?

The central point of the analysis is the cross. In his video, Silva reads four texts from White — from The Acts of the Apostles, The Desire of Ages, Exalt Him and a 1900 manuscript — stating that Christ's sacrifice was broad, complete and finished on the cross. Gleyson responds with the same author: in The Great Controversy, White writes that, upon entering the Most Holy Place in 1844, Christ had only completed one part of His work as intercessor, in order to begin another — the final work of atonement; that for eighteen centuries the sins of repentant believers, though forgiven, remained in the record books, not blotted out; and that the High Priest entered the Most Holy Place to carry out the investigative judgment and to make atonement for all who are found entitled to its benefits. The official doctrine confirms this, in fundamental belief 24: in 1844, Christ began "the second and final phase of His atoning ministry." If the atonement was complete on the cross, Gleyson concludes, there is no investigative judgment — and without it, the Adventist church loses its very reason for existing, for that was the message that, according to Hiram Edson's account corroborated by White, God gave to this people. The Bible the trio then reads says something else: by His own blood, Christ entered the Most Holy Place once for all, obtaining eternal redemption (Hebrews 9:12); whoever hears the word and believes does not come into judgment, but has passed from death to life (John 5:24).

It is this system, they argue, that provides the real context for White's statement that Silva presented as pastoral caution — that a convert should never be taught to say or feel that he is saved. In the Adventist context, Wagner explains, insecurity is not humility: it is the investigative judgment, in which angels record every act, word and thought in order to justify or condemn, and in which salvation is maintained by keeping the commandments — beginning with the Sabbath — and the rules of health reform, to the point that White writes, in Last Day Events, that many who are only half converted regarding eating meat will fall away from God's people. Against this, Gleyson reads Romans 8:1: there is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus. This is not, they insist, about perfectionism or a license to sin — it is about knowing where the guarantee lies: in Christ's work or in the believer's daily performance.

Porta antiga de madeira entreaberta com feixe de luz entrando em interior escuro e empoeirado

The shut-door doctrine: after 1844, according to White, the door of the Holy Place was shut — and salvation came to depend on accepting the movement's new "light."

Babylon: The Entire Chapter That Became "Slavery"

The longest clash is over a chapter. Cited by critics, the passage from Early Writings in which White declares that, ever since the second angel proclaimed the fall of the churches in 1844, they have become more and more corrupt, that Satan has taken full possession of them all and that their prayers are an abomination to God was explained by Silva as a text about slavery. Gleyson then reads the entire chapter — "The Sins of Babylon" — on the screen. The chapter speaks of churches that bear the name of followers of Christ but are indistinguishable from the world; of ministers who preach smooth things; of the spirit of the world at enmity with God; of churches turned into a cage of every unclean and hateful bird — and only at the end, almost as an appendix, does it arrive at the slave trade, one of the sins of the time. In the same chapter, White states that slaveholders would face the seven last plagues and the second death: with the abolition of slavery in the United States in 1865, and the death of all involved, Gleyson notes, the prophecy became impossible — a false prophecy within the very chapter used in the defense. And he also reads the neighboring pages: the nominal churches would have "crucified" the three angels' messages as the Jews crucified Jesus; their prayers would be useless, directed to a compartment from which Jesus has already departed; the honest children of God still in them will come out before the plagues and take their stand with the remnant. The historical context, the three acknowledge, was the resentment of a group expelled and mocked after 1844 — but it is the text, carried over to the present day, that shapes the mindset of today's member.

The Vision of the Prayers and the Door That Was Shut in 1844

Silva also stated that, in the chapter of the vision cited by critics — in which Satan breathes a malignant influence upon those who pray "Father, give us Thy Spirit" — the word "church" does not even appear: White would be describing only two groups at the return of Jesus. The response reads the vision from the beginning: before the throne, White says she saw the Advent people, the church and the world. The group that remains bowed in prayer after Jesus rises and is taken, in a chariot of clouds, to the Most Holy Place — while Satan, beside the throne, breathes dark light upon it instead of the Spirit — is, in the trio's reading, the portrait of the churches that rejected the messages of 1844. And everything connects to the shut-door doctrine, read on pages 42 and 43 of the same book: in an 1849 vision, the commandments of God and the testimony of Jesus with reference to the shut door could not be separated; the door of the Holy Place was shut in 1844, no one can open it, and God's people came to be tested on the truth of the Sabbath. Gleyson also recalls the extreme consequence the doctrine had at the time: children born after 1844 came to be treated as children of Satan, because the door of grace was shut — and no Adventist pastor, they observe, stands up today to say that White was wrong when she affirmed that God showed her that.

Brothers — Until They Are Converted: Sunday Decree and Proselytism

To support the claim that the church sees other Christians as brothers, Silva read a policy adopted in 1926 by the General Conference executive committee, which recognizes organizations that uplift Christ as part of the divine plan of evangelization. Gleyson responds that the obscure policy is not what the member reads: White wrote that the distinction between the loyal and the disloyal is made by keeping the fourth commandment Sabbath — whoever does not keep it does not serve God — and described, for the final conflict, Romanists and Protestants united to impose Sunday, with oppressive laws and a decree against the commandment keepers. And there is a point Rodrigo sums up in a single sentence: there is no return of Jesus in Adventism without a Sunday decree. The second coming is made conditional on an act of human governments, which Paul never announced — on the contrary, he treated days, festivals and sabbaths as a shadow of things to come (Colossians 2:16-17) and left each person fully convinced in his own mind regarding days (Romans 14:5).

Proselytism, finally, is not an outside impression: it is in the texts. White wrote that there is a work to be done for ministers of other churches, for God wants them to be saved — and that Adventist ministers should seek to draw near to the ministers of other denominations; a Sabbath School lesson repeated the instruction, adding the strategy of not using denunciatory speeches, so as not to close the doors to truth. And Mark Finley's book Studying Together teaches the step by step: approach Baptist friends through points in common, do not immediately enter into the discussion of the Sabbath; when the love of Jesus dominates their hearts, then explain the truths peculiar to Adventists. For the trio, this is exactly Silva's strategy: preach a neutral gospel, be respectful, plant curiosity — while the Adventist pulpit is never yielded in the opposite direction.

The Letter to His Sister and the "Jesus + Something" Test

One of the most beautiful texts in Silva's video is a letter from White to her own sister, urging her simply to accept Jesus as Savior and to return to the fellowship of her church — with no mention of the Sabbath, Adventism or commandments. Rodrigo reads the letter with a different key: it is the "speaking out of both sides of one's mouth" that he calls cultural in Adventism. For the family, the simple gospel, because she knew what the sister needed to be saved; for the system, 28 beliefs, a baptismal record and the prophetess as a condition. And he cites the didactic test of an evangelical pastor: to be saved, one must accept Jesus — any addition presented as a condition ("accept Jesus + this here") attributes a saving function to something other than Christ. The challenge Wagner leaves to Silva is symmetrical: prepare that sermon — "you need nothing to be saved, only Christ Jesus" — and preach it, sustaining it to the end, inside an Adventist church.

The Prophetess in the Place of the Son

The trio's conclusion finally answers the question in the title. Why "sect"? Because no founder or author of any other Christian tradition said of himself what White said, according to the readings in the video: in a 1900 letter, she affirms that the Holy Spirit is the author of the Scriptures and of the Spirit of Prophecy — her writings; her books would contain the truth for this time, to be proclaimed in all parts of the world; the Holy Spirit would have written His truths in her heart and mind infallibly; and the light God gave her will condemn all who choose not to accept and obey it. The final piece is a rereading of Hebrews: where the apostle writes that, in these last days, God has spoken to us by His Son, the text from Testimonies read in the video declares that, in these days, He speaks through the testimonies of His Spirit — her writings occupying the place of God's final speech. The three close with the same invitation as at the beginning: do not take anyone's word for it; go to the primary sources, read the entire chapters and decide. And they thank the pastors who took a stand in the controversy — among them Tarles Elias, Eliseu Rodrigues, João Flávio Martinez, Paulo Cristiano, Paulo Batista and Mário Baio — reminding listeners that the channels and supporting materials are available to anyone who wishes to study the subject in depth.

Read Also

Read also: Honoris causa for White? 50 Statements Silva Defends →

Read also: The Shut Door of 1844 and the End of Grace →

Read also: What Makes Adventism a Sect →

Watch the Full Response

The full analysis — more than three hours of readings and commentary — is in the video below:

Watch on YouTube: Response to Rodrigo Silva: The Adventist Church Is a Sect — Ex-Adventists →