Ellen White

Adventist historians expose Atkinson's fanaticism

With an introduction by Rodrigo, the video presents the roundtable published by Spectrum magazine in 1987: the Adventist historians Fred Hoyt, Rene Noorbergen, Jonathan Butler and…

By Rodrigo Custódio ·

Adventist historians expose Atkinson's fanaticism

In 1987, the Adventist magazine Spectrum published a rare conversation: four historians from the Seventh-day Adventist Church itself — professors at Adventist universities and a former White Estate employee — reacting, with no defensive script, to the transcript of an 1845 trial. The defendant was Israel Dammon, one of the leaders of the fanatical Atkinson group in Maine; the young Ellen Harmon, aged 17, was in the midst of that night. This one-hour video presents the conversation in full, preceded by a long introduction by Rodrigo, who translates for a Brazilian audience a debate the historians conducted in English — and which, according to him, many pastors prefer not to mention.

Who the four historians are

The participants introduced in the video are Fred Hoyt, professor of history and political science at Loma Linda University — it was he who found the trial account while combing through Maine newspapers from the period 1827 to 1846; Rene Noorbergen, assistant professor also at Loma Linda and editor of the review section of Spectrum, who edited the transcripts of the conversation; Jonathan Butler, professor at the University of California, Riverside, PhD from the University of Chicago and author of extensive studies on Adventist history; and Ron Graybill, associate professor of history at Loma Linda, PhD from Johns Hopkins University, who worked for thirteen years at the White Estate, the center that houses Ellen White's writings in Washington. They are not outside critics: they are, as the video's introduction observes, central names in modern Adventist historiography.

The trial of Israel Dammon

Dammon was accused, according to the transcript discussed by the historians, of being a vagabond and an idle person: he went about the town of Atkinson begging, neglected work, squandered his earnings and failed to provide for his family — conduct that, under the laws of New England at the time, was a crime, in a farming region that depended on everyone's labor. The witnesses were local residents, mostly farmers, and justices of the peace presided over the proceedings. The verdict was guilty, with a sentence of ten days' imprisonment in Bangor — a penalty Dammon never served: he appealed, and the case was annulled before the next session of the court. The defense attorney, James S. Holmes, took up the cause not out of Millerite sympathy, but because he understood it to be an invasion of religious liberty.

Interior rústico de madeira de um tribunal americano dos anos 1840, com mesa do juiz, martelo, vela acesa e cadeiras vazias sob a luz fria de uma janela com neve

A wooden courthouse in 1840s Maine: it was before justices of the peace and farmer neighbors that the Dammon case was heard, in February 1845.

The night in Atkinson, according to the witnesses

The point the historians emphasize is the degree of agreement between prosecution and defense: with a single exception — the enigmatic expression that Ellen Harmon was called an "imitation of Christ" — the defense witnesses corroborated practically everything the prosecution witnesses said. And what they said forms a picture difficult to reconcile with the later image of the prophetess: there were kisses — the "holy kiss," extended also to the sisters —, people crawling on the floor like children, based on the literal reading that one must humble oneself like a little child to enter heaven; shouting; foot washing; repeated rebaptisms, including in the middle of the night, at the height of winter, with an average temperature of around 7 degrees below zero. Harmon spent six to seven hours lying on the floor, on a pillow, going in and out of trance, while a man cradled her head — and, from the trance, ordered someone to go to the stream to be baptized.

"There is no evidence that she condemned it"

The central question of the roundtable is direct: to what extent were Ellen and James White implicated in that fanaticism? The historians list the practices of the time — trances, shouting, rebaptism, crawling, rolling on the floor, the holy kiss, kissing the feet, the shut door, deliberate refusal to work — and identify Harmon with several of them: shouting, rebaptism, the holy kiss, trances, the shut door and foot washing. More importantly: nothing in the document indicates that she distanced herself from what was happening around her. Years later, White claimed that she had always fought fanaticism; the 1845 transcript, the historians observe, places her psychologically much closer to it than the church imagined. The young woman lying on the floor, in a "community of ecstasy," is very different from the later figure, standing before a silent audience as the only person in vision.

Two versions of the same arrest

The contrast appears sharply in the episode of Dammon's arrest. In the account White published in 1860, in Spiritual Gifts, volume 2, the officials entered the house, seized the elder by the arms and legs, but could only drag him a few inches: "the power of God was in that room," and the men ran outside, unable to bear the divine presence. The trial document tells another story: there were women clinging to Dammon, who would not let him go. One of the historians summarizes the problem: if we had only her version, we would never imagine Ellen White in a scene like that — we would imagine her arriving, condemning everything and clearing the place before the police appeared. In later editions of her autobiography, in 1880, 1888 and 1915, the town of Atkinson and the names of Dammon and the rival visionary Dorinda Baker simply disappear.

"She wanted to forget Atkinson and Dammon."

Why she survived — and the other visionaries did not

The roundtable also confronts the sociological question: in 1845, there were several approved visionaries in the same environment — Dorinda Baker, Emily Clemons, Mary Hamlin — as well as William Foy. Why did only Ellen Harmon become the prophetess of a worldwide movement? The historians' answer involves the symbiotic relationship with James White: "charisma without order tends to disappear." It was the couple who transformed visions into an institution: a publishing house, a health reform institute, a medical school. Before that, however, there was failure: in Maine and New England, the group was seen as a bizarre band — White herself would write, in 1874, that that fanaticism caused "a terrible stain" on the cause, which would cling to the name of Adventism "like leprosy." Distance and time were needed: the move West, to Michigan and California, allowed the past to be remembered selectively — and allowed the movement to gradually discipline the practices that had launched it.

The discomfort that remains

In the end, the historians do not hide their discomfort. One of them observes that, setting aside the formation of doctrines, the bare fact remains: the woman whom Adventists believe received communications from God is lying on the floor, in that chaos, having an experience identified as a divine message — and that no living Adventist would recognize that kind of phenomenon as the work of God. Another admits the embarrassment of thinking that the White Estate might have known the document all along — though he concludes he is "as certain as I can be" that the center never knew of it. The roundtable's prediction for members is sober: scandal, then denial, then a growing distrust of the roots — until many take up religious life again, but without the naive view of their own past. It is this internal debate, conducted by historians of the church itself nearly forty years ago, that the video now places before the Brazilian public.

Read also

Read also: She banned hats in vision; the 1905 photo contradicts this →

Read also: The Atkinson Nights scandal buried for 175 years →

Read also: The trial of Israel Dammon and the young Ellen Harmon →

Watch the full video

The complete conversation of the four historians, with Rodrigo's introduction, is in the video below:

Watch on YouTube: Adventist Historians and Ellen White's Fanaticism in Atkinson →