Investigative Judgment

Jesus entered the Most Holy Place at the ascension, not in 1844

A confused member reading Hebrews 6:19-20, a pastor who admits he cannot affirm that Jesus remained in the Holy Place, and a reading of the Greek text that points to the innermost veil…

By Rodrigo Custódio ·

Jesus entered the Most Holy Place at the ascension, not in 1844

In 1844, Christ passed into the Most Holy Place of the heavenly sanctuary to carry out the final work of atonement — this is what Ellen White wrote in Manuscript 13, of 1889, and in The Great Controversy. In this video, Rodrigo places three Adventist voices before the same letter to the Hebrews and shows the knot that arises when the text is read without the lens of 1844: a confused member, a pastor who declares he cannot affirm it, and a scholar who, following Greek grammar, concludes the opposite of the official doctrine.

Two kinds of pastors

Before the statements, Rodrigo draws a distinction. On one side would be the pastors whose practical function is to keep members inside the church — tithing, giving offerings and volunteering — even if to do so they must place Ellen White above the Bible. On the other, Adventist pastors with solid academic training, who sit at the table with masters and doctors from other denominations and need to preserve their own name: a doctor in Theology, Rodrigo argues, cannot read Hebrews and simply reconcile the text with White's statement. It is from this tension that the moments shown in the video are born.

The member's question: "I remained confused"

The first voice is that of an ordinary Adventist reading Hebrews 6:19-20. The text says that hope is an anchor for the soul, which penetrates beyond the veil, where Jesus entered as a forerunner, high priest forever after the order of Melchizedek. The member confesses his confusion: according to the text, Jesus already entered the Most Holy Place at his ascension — so how is this to be harmonized with the idea that he would have worked in the Holy Place until 1844 and only then passed into the Most Holy Place, where the investigative judgment would begin?

Véu azul e roxo do templo entre colunas douradas, com feixe de luz atravessando a abertura

Beyond the veil: the Greek expression in Hebrews 6 points to the innermost veil, the one that separated the Holy Place from the Most Holy Place.

The careful answer: "we have no way of saying"

The pastor who responds upholds the official line: Christ exercises a ministry in heaven; upon ascending, he performed a work of intercession in the first compartment, the Holy Place, and after 1844 he took on another function, that of Judge. But he admits the difficulty: there is no way to say, on the basis of Hebrews 6:19-20, that Christ entered directly into the Most Holy Place and remained there. The reason alleged is linguistic: the Greek word for veil, katapetasma, would designate three veils of the sanctuary — the one at the entrance to the courtyard, the one at the entrance to the sanctuary, and the one that separated the Holy Place from the Most Holy Place — so that it would be "very complicated" to know to which of them Hebrews refers. The purpose of the letter's author, he concludes, would not be that.

The Greek reading: the innermost veil

The third voice examines precisely that way out. The same pastor, pausing on the complete phrase of Hebrews 6:19 — esôteron tou katapetasmatos, "beyond the veil", literally "the innermost part of the veil" — observes that this expression, in the Greek version of the Old Testament, is used solely and exclusively for the veil that separated the Holy Place from the Most Holy Place. The term "innermost" appears with the same meaning in 1 Samuel 24 (the innermost part of the cave), in 2 Chronicles 4:22 (the innermost part of the sanctuary) and in Acts 16:24 (the innermost prison). From the linguistic standpoint, the exposition concludes, when interpreting Scripture by Scripture itself, Jesus entered, at the ascension, beyond the innermost veil — that is, into the Most Holy Place.

This hope "penetrates beyond the veil", where Jesus entered for us (Heb 6:19-20).

Why this is so serious

Rodrigo closes by underscoring the size of the consequence. If Jesus has been in the Most Holy Place since the ascension, around the year 31, there is no transition in 1844 to explain — and it is precisely the transition that set off the whole movement: the investigative judgment, the purification of the sanctuary and, with them, the reason for Adventism's existence as the remnant church. Without 1844, everything is muddled: when would the final atonement have taken place? That is why, the video concludes, Hebrews 6:19-20 is a text that Adventist apologetics needs to work around — and that, read in full, its own scholars have difficulty working around.

Read also

Read also: Obelisk, all-seeing eye: the Masonic shadow of the SDA Church →

Read also: Christ entered the Most Holy Place at the ascension, not in 1844 →

Read also: Hebrews 9 says once for all →

Watch the full video

The three statements, in the order in which they aired, are in the video below:

Watch on YouTube: 3 Adventists and a False Prophetess →