Ellen White

Jesus or White: Who Is the Spirit of Prophecy?

Excerpt from a 3:56 study on Revelation 19:10. The presenter maintains that the entire book of Revelation is the revelation and testimony of Jesus Himself — and confronts this text with the use made…

By Rodrigo Custódio ·

Jesus or White: Who Is the Spirit of Prophecy?

In less than four minutes, this study excerpt on the Para que Possamos channel revolves around a single phrase, that of Revelation 19:10: "the testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy." The question in the title — Jesus or Ellen White? — arises from the contrast between what the biblical text says and the use that, according to the presenter, Ellen White made of this expression to speak of her own books.

What Revelation Calls the Testimony of Jesus

The study begins with the book itself. Revelation 1:1 presents the work as "the revelation of Jesus Christ, which God gave him" — and, at the end of the book, it is Jesus Himself who testifies of these things. Putting the two ends together, the presenter argues, the entire book of Revelation is a testimony of Jesus, given by Jesus: the "spirit of prophecy" of 19:10 points to that testimony, not to a nineteenth-century library. It is from this reading that he asks the following question: how did the Adventist prophetess understand — and use — this passage?

The Same Origin for the Bible and for Her Books

The presenter then brings three texts from Ellen White, beginning with a statement in which she attributes to the Holy Spirit the authorship of both the Scriptures and what she calls the Spirit of Prophecy:

The Holy Spirit is the author of the Scriptures and of the Spirit of Prophecy.

His commentary is direct: in this usage, "spirit of prophecy" refers to her books. She does not declare, he observes, that her writings are equal to the Bible — but she places them in parallel with it as to origin: the same divine Author for the Scriptures and for the so-called "lesser light." And it is this parallel, the study maintains, that does the heavy lifting within the system: if the origin is the same, disagreeing with her books comes to sound like disagreeing with the Bible.

Bíblia antiga aberta sob feixe de luz sobre mesa de madeira, ao lado de livros antigos na sombra

A beam of light on an open Bible — and, in the shadow beside it, the books that the video accuses of having been placed in parallel with it.

Jesus or White?

The excerpt ends where it began: in the dispute over a biblical title. For the presenter, Revelation 19:10 exalts the testimony of Jesus — the spirit of prophecy is His. When the expression becomes, in practice, the official name of the writings of a nineteenth-century author, the center shifts: the testimony of Jesus comes to be measured, explained and, at the limit, completed by the testimony about Jesus that she produced. The question in the title thus remains as a simple test for the reader to apply with the Bible open: who occupies, in your faith, the place that the text reserves for the testimony of Jesus?

Read also

Read also: The penny dropped live: 'the Holy Spirit is Jesus' →

Read also: Ellen White judged mesmerism by vision, not by the Bible →

Read also: 1844, the Investigative Judgment and the Prophetic Authority of Ellen White →

Watch the full study

In four minutes, the study goes from Revelation 19:10 to the three texts from White and to the parallel between the Bible and her books:

Watch on YouTube: Jesus or Ellen White? Who Is the Spirit of Prophecy? →